Information courtesy of NJAC Sports web site www.njacsports.com. Highlighted players are from New Jersey and it shows that a player can be from any school to become a good college football player.
| OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: Connor Cox, Frostburg State | ||||
| SAM MILLS DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: Mauro Altamura, Montclair State | ||||
| SPECIAL TEAMS PLAYER OF THE YEAR: Corterris Simpson, Wesley | ||||
| OFFENSIVE ROOKIE OF THE YEAR: Dave Jachera, TCNJ | ||||
| DEFENSIVE ROOKIE OF THE YEAR: Anthony Bassani, Kean | ||||
| COACH OF THE YEAR: DeLane Fitzgerald, Frostburg State | ||||
| FIRST TEAM OFFENSE | ||||
| Name | Year | Pos. | School | Hometown/High School |
| Connor Cox* | SR | QB | Frostburg State | Davidson, MD/South River |
| E.J. Lee* | JR | RB | Wesley | Germantown, MD/Northwest |
| Akiva Wedge | JR | RB | Southern Virginia | Forestville, MD/Frederick Douglas |
| Kadarrius Campbell | SR | FB | Salisbury | Waldorf, MD/St. Mary’s Ryken |
| Joshua Davis | SR | WR | Christopher Newport | Farmville, VA/Fuqua School |
| Alex Kemp*^! | SR | WR | Wesley | Magnolia, DE/Caesar Rodney |
| Malik Morris | JR | WR | Frostburg State | Carney, MD/Dunbar |
| Ruhann Peele | JR | WR | Wesley | Linden, NJ/Linden |
| Andrew Eagle+ | SR | TE | Wesley | Odenton, MD/Arundel |
| Riley Hartman~ | SR | OL | Frostburg State | Leesburg, VA/Tuscarora |
| Andrew Houck~ | SR | OL | Salisbury | Salisbury, MD/Wicomico |
| Jon Koonce | SR | OL | Montclair State | Cliffside Park, NJ/Cliffside Park |
| Joey Powell | SR | OL | Frostburg State | Abingdon, MD/Edgewood |
| Matt Rittenhouse~ | JR | OL | Christopher Newport | Broadway, VA/Broadway |
| Chris Vurchio | SR | OL | Kean | Hazlet, NJ/Raritan |
| FIRST TEAM DEFENSE | ||||
| Name | Year | Pos. | School | Hometown/High School |
| David Gajderowicz | JR | DL | Rowan | Medford, NJ/Shawnee |
| Ben James | JR | DL | Christopher Newport | Virginia Beach, VA/Kellam |
| DeShawn Reed | JR | DL | Kean | Jersey City, NJ/Hoboken |
| Damon Small Jr. | SR | DL | Kean | Bayonne, NJ/Bayonne |
| Zach Strand | SO | DL | Frostburg State | Easton, MD/Easton |
| Mauro Altamura+ | SR | LB | Montclair State | Hasbrouck Heights, NJ/Hasbrouck Heights |
| Patrick Bernado | JR | LB | Salisbury | Potomac, MD/Wooton |
| Dante Capozzoli | SO | LB | Kean | Caldwell, NJ/James Caldwell |
| Charles Faulkner~$ | SR | LB | William Paterson | Carteret, NJ/Carteret |
| Shane Gaines | SR | CB | Salisbury | Baltimore, MD/Owings Mills |
| Isiah Mitchell | SO | CB | Wesley | Middletown, DE/Middletown |
| Anthony Taylor | SR | CB | Frostburg State | Takoma Park, MD/Montgomery Blair |
| Neil Davis~ | JR | S | Southern Virginia | Salem, UT/Salem Hills |
| Damian Jiggetts | JR | S | Christopher Newport | Norfolk, VA/Booker T. Washington |
| Cappadonna Miller* | SR | S | Wesley | Bridgeton, NJ/Bridgeton |
| FIRST TEAM SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||
| Name | Year | Pos. | School | Hometown/High School |
| Zach Warcola*^ | JR | P | TCNJ | Mendham, NJ/Mendham |
| Hunter Daly* | SR | K | Montclair State | Neptune, NJ/Neptune |
| Kason Campbell | JR | RET | Montclair State | Elizabeth, NJ/Elizabeth |
| Elijah Rehm | JR | RET | Rowan | Clayton, NJ/Clayton |
| SECOND TEAM OFFENSE | ||||
| Name | Year | Pos. | School | Hometown/High School |
| Jack Anderson | JR | QB | Christopher Newport | Great Falls, VA/Langley |
| Ja’Quill Burch | SO | QB | Montclair State | Elizabeth, NJ/Elizabeth |
| John Mannion | SR | RB | Rowan | Verona, NJ/James Caldwell |
| Jamaal Morant~ | SR | RB | Frostburg State | Baltimore, MD/Milford Mill |
| Craig Merkle | SO | FB | Montclair State | Nutley, NJ/Nutley |
| Cole Blais | SO | WR | Christopher Newport | Virginia Beach, VA/Kellam |
| Kason Campbell | JR | WR | Montclair State | Elizabeth, NJ/Elizabeth |
| Jack Clevenger | JR | WR | TCNJ | Roxbury, NJ/Roxbury |
| Elijah Rehm | JR | WR | Rowan | Clayton, NJ/Clayton |
| Grayson Boyce | SR | TE | Frostburg State | Poquoson, VA/Poquoson |
| Stephen Gaffney+ | JR | OL | Montclair State | Oakland, NJ/Indian Hills |
| O’Shane McCall+ | SR | OL | Frostburg State | Upper Marlboro, MD/Wise |
| George Morton | SR | OL | Salisbury | Northfield, NJ/Mainland Regional |
| Grady Sami | JR | OL | Southern Virginia | Colorado Springs, CO/Sierra |
| Jordan Sawyer | SR | OL | Christopher Newport | Norfolk, VA/Norview |
| SECOND TEAM DEFENSE | ||||
| Name | Year | Pos. | School | Hometown/High School |
| Isaac Johnson | SR | DL | Salisbury | Salisbury, MD/Parkside |
| Matthew McFarland | JR | DL | Salisbury | Bowie, MD/Eleanor Roosevelt |
| Kevin Stokes* | SR | DL | Rowan | Mays Landing, NJ/Oakcrest |
| Jake Weber+ | SR | DL | Montclair State | Matawan, NJ/Matawan |
| Max Busca+ | SR | LB | TCNJ | Medford, NJ/Shawnee |
| Jayson Gonzalez | SR | LB | Rowan | Roselle Park, NJ/Roselle Park |
| Harold Kwigova | JR | LB | Salisbury | Silver Spring, MD/John F. Kennedy |
| Dre’Quan Reed^ | SR | LB | Frostburg State | Columbia, MD/Hammond |
| Travelle Curry | SR | CB | Rowan | Paterson, NJ/Passaic County Tech |
| Daquay Harris-Winbush | SR | CB | Wesley | Arlington, VA/Washington & Lee |
| D.J. Wright | SO | CB | Christopher Newport | Woodbridge, VA/C.D. Hylton |
| Jaier Garrett | JR | S | Montclair State | Monmouth Junction, NJ/South Brunswick |
| Vincent Persichetti | JR | S | Frostburg State | Pittsburgh, PA/Baldwin |
| Xavier Santos | JR | S | TCNJ | Westampton, NJ/Rancocas Valley |
| SECOND TEAM SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||
| Name | Year | Pos. | School | Hometown/High School |
| Hunter Daly | SR | P | Montclair State | Neptune, NJ/Neptune |
| Trevor Skoglund | SR | K | Salisbury | Easton, MD/Easton |
| Terrell Brown | SO | RET | Frostburg State | Accokeek, MD/Gwynn Park |
| Paris Crawford | JR | RET | Kean | Bayonne, NJ/Bayonne |
| HONORABLE MENTION | ||||
| Name | Year | Pos. | School | Hometown/High School |
| Khaaliq Burroughs* | SR | QB | Wesley | Palmyra, NJ/Paul VI |
| Anthony Diorio | SR | RB | Rowan | Medford, NJ/Shawnee |
| Brian Kowalczyk | JR | TE | Montclair State | Wallington, NJ/Wallington |
| Noah Teeter | SR | TE | Frostburg State | Hancock, MD/Hancock |
| Scott Dunscomb | SO | OL | Rowan | Hamilton, NJ/Hamilton West |
| Tyler Norwood | JR | OL | Salisbury | Milford, DE/Milford |
| Richie Squeo | FR | OL | William Paterson | Keansburg, NJ/Keansburg |
| Davonte Vivian | FR | OL | Kean | Beverly, NJ/Palmyra |
| Dallin Breen | SO | DL | Southern Virginia | Las Vegas, NV/Cimarron Memorial |
| Jemel Daniels | JR | DL | Kean | Old Bridge, NJ/Old Bridge |
| Erik Graham | JR | DL | TCNJ | Oceanport, NJ/Shore Regional |
| Walter Riley | JR | DL | Frostburg State | Rohrersville, MD/Boonsboro |
| Corey Anthony+ | JR | LB | William Paterson | Hopewell Junction, NY/John Jay |
| Godwin Asamoah | SR | LB | Rowan | Edison, NJ/Edison |
| Giuseppe Gugliuzza | SR | LB | Montclair State | North Arlington, NJ/North Arlington |
| Gavin Liepe | SO | LB | TCNJ | Mays Landing, NJ/Holy Spirit |
| Tom Montag | SR | LB | Salisbury | Elkridge, MD/Long Reach |
| Brennan Ray | FR | LB | Montclair State | Woodbine, NJ/Lower Cape May |
| Conner Ryan | JR | LB | Christopher Newport | Aldie, VA/John Champe |
| Sal Tardogno | FR | LB | TCNJ | Manalapan, NJ/Manalapan |
| Jalen Harris | SO | CB | Montclair State | Carteret, NJ/Carteret |
| Sean Carroll | SO | S | Salisbury | Wilmington, DE/Mount Pleasant |
| Dylan Elliott | SR | S | Montclair State | Westfield, NJ/Westfield |
| Albert Green IV | SO | S | Southern Virginia | Tucson, AZ/Sabino |
| B.J. Hill+ | SR | S | Christopher Newport | Bluffton, SC/Bluffton |
| Coray Williams | JR | S | Wesley | Sayreville, NJ/Sayreville |
|
Key: * -First Team NJAC All-Conference 2017 ~ -Second Team NJAC All-Conference 2017 + -Honorable Mention NJAC 2017 ^ – First Team NJAC All-Conference 2016 $ – Honorable Mention NJAC 2016 ! – Honorable Mention NJAC 2015 |
||||