Post 1,869 – Newton 26 Cedar Grove 21

Newton 26 Cedar Grove 21 

November 20, 2026

Newton was led by the running of Evan Cotter and took advantage of two Cedar Grove fumbles in the fourth quarter, scoring the go-ahead touchdown and running out the final six minutes to win, 26-21, and capture the North Jersey Group 1 regional championship. They will meet Schalick next week for the state championship in a battle of undefeated teams. 

First Quarter: Cedar Grove opened the game on their 35. On the second play, Jake Catanzarite took the handoff. He handed off to Chris Miller, who ran around the left end before cutting across the field, outrunning several Newton defenders for a 68-yard touchdown and a 7-0 Cedar Grove lead. 

After exchanging punts, Newton had the ball on their 15. Reid Corino immediately gained 26 yards to the 41. An Evan Cotter 4-yard run plus a personal foul on Cedar Grove brought the ball to the Cedar Grove 40.  The Braves got a first down before Cole Young connected with Corrino in the far left corner of the end zone for a 14-yard touchdown. 

A 14-yard run by Catanzarite brought the ball to the Newton 49-yard line, and two plays later, he gained 17 yards to the 31. But the Panthers’ hopes ended when Hunter Wolfe intercepted the ball in the end zone.  

Newton drove on three plays – all runs by Cotter: a 49-yard run, another for 4, and the last a 22-yard touchdown around right end, to go ahead 14-7, one play into the second quarter. 

Second Quarter: Cedar Grove moved the ball behind Catanzarite’s running, advancing as far as the 18, but two incomplete passes gave the ball to Newton. 

Newton took over on their 18 and had a 14-yard run by Cotter, followed by a 10-yard run two plays later. Their fourth-down pass to Noah Decker fell one yard short, giving the ball to Cedar Grove on their 43. 

A Cedar Grove pass to Jack Velonas gained 32 yards to the Newton 25, and they scored on a 26-yard pass to Velonas to tie the score at 14 with 2:47 left in the half. 

Newton went on a 9-play drive with Cotter getting 33 yards to the 50. The Braves made it to the end zone behind Cotter, who scored from a yard out with 19 seconds left in the half. The extra point was blocked by John Policano to make it 20-14, Newton. 

Third Quarter:  Cedar Grove moved down the field behind a 56-yard run by Catanzarite to the 16. Mille scored on a 3-yard run, and the converted extra point put the Panthers ahead, 21-20.    

Fourth Quarter: Newton had a drive going, and a 36-yard completion from Cole Young to Decker had them on the Cedar Grove 41. But a fourth-down completion to Hunter Wolfe was ruled out of bounds, and Cedar Grove took over on their 42. 

On third down, a double handoff to Miller was fumbled when Brayden Alpaugh got penetration and forced a fumble, recovered by Tim McNamara for Newton on the Cedar Grove 31. 

Cotter immediately gained 13 to the 18-yard line. Two plays later, Braxton Guerra scored on a 14-yard run, running through a defender. The two-point attempt was incomplete, and Newton led, 26-21, with 6:34 remaining. 

Disaster struck immediately for Cedar Grove. Velonas took the direct snap and ran into Miller on a counter-play handoff and fumbled, with Caulder Tellbuescher recovering for Newton on the Cedar Grove 37. 

Newton did a great job, picked up three first downs on short runs, and ran out the final 6:24. 

Comments: Cotter was the workhorse for Newton. He had 37 carries for 229 yards and 2 touchdowns, and the Braves gained 291 on the ground. They did a masterful job running out the last six-plus minutes of the game. Their defense was opportunistic, recovering two fourth-quarter fumbles. 

It was a tough loss for Cedar Grove. It was anybody’s game in the fourth quarter, and the two fumbles killed them. They moved the ball, with Catanzarite gaining 143 yards on 16 carries and Miler with 90 on 6. They had a 21-20 lead and moved the ball up to that point, but the fumbles did not give them that opportunity to do more.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.