Red Bank Catholic Caseys

July 7, 2024

2023: 

• 10-1 
• Won the Non-Public B championship by beating DePaul in the finals and Holy Spirit in the semifinals 
• Wins included Donovan Catholic, Toms River North, Seton Hall Prep, and Middletown South 
• Their lone loss  was to Bergen Catholic 
• Scored 298 points for a27.09 average 
• Allowed 144 points for a 13.09 average  

Graduation: 

• LB Davin Brewton – Pittsburgh 
• WR/DB Emmanuel Ross – Syracuse 
• OL Tyler Burnham – Delaware 
• DL Avery Barnes – Monmouth 
• OL/DL Lorenzo Portella – Lehigh (Pa.) 
• WR Jack Bohm-Squicciarini – Bucknell (Pa.) 
• WR/DB Stephen Myers –  Marist (NY) 
• P Vincent Muscillo – Wagner (NY) 
• TE/LB Luke Krzyzkowski – Stonehill (Mass.) 
• K Justin LaMorte – Catholic U (DC) 
• OL Patrick Magee – Wilkes (Pa.) 
• DL Logan Graham – Merrimack (Mass.) 

Offense: 

• Formation: Multiple Spread 
• Returning Starters: 4  

Quarterback: 

• Frankie Williams, Senior, 6-0-½, 185 – 3-year starter; passed for 1,631 yards, 19 touchdowns with 3 interceptions, and rushed for 449 yards per nj.com 

Running Back: 

• Matt Lonczak, Senior, 5-9, 200 – returning co-starter 
• Jamie Gutridge, Senior, 5-9, 195 – in the mix; saw action and started on defense 
• Luke Lonczak, Sophomore, 5-9, 185 – in the mix; saw action late in the year 
• Jordan Mosenthine, Sophomore, 5-10, 180 – in the mix 
• Luke Scaturro, Sophomore, 5-8, 180 – in the mix 

Wide Receiver: 

• Daniel Zabora, Junior, 6-3, 185 – returning starter 
• Johnny Williams, Junior, 5-9, 160 – returning starter in the slot 
• Chris Gibson, Junior, 5-9, 170 – projected starter 
• Blake Caruso, Junior, 5-11, 180 – part of the rotation; started on defense 
• Jason Berecsky, Freshman, 5-11, 175 – part of the rotation 
• Kieran McGonnell, Sophomore, 6-0, 175 – part of the rotation  

Tight End: 

• TJ Walsh, Sophomore, 6-2, 210 – will see action 
• Aiden Funk, Junior, 6-2, 200 – will see action 
• Lorenzo Tartamella, Sophomore, 6-3, 220 – provides depth; started on defense 

Offensive Line: 

• Frank Sinatra, Senior, 5-11, 215 – projected starter at center 
• Gavin O’Malley, Senior, 5-11, 230 – projected starter at guard 
• Joe Amadeo, Sophomore, 6-0, 250 – competing at guard 
• Adrian Piesco, Junior, 6-2, 245 – competing at tackle 
• Jordan Key, Sophomore, 6-2, 235 – competing at tackle 
• Jack Main, Junior, 6-2, 230 – competing at tackle 
• Lucas Faas, Sophomore, 6-2, 290 – competing at tackle 

Defense: 

• Formation: Multiple 3-and-4-man fronts 
• Returning Starters: 

Defensive Line: 

• Lorenzo Tartamella, Sophomore, 6-3, 220 – returning starter at end 
• James Forsyth, Senior, 6-4, 205 – projected starter at end 
• Carmine Tartamella, Senior, 6-2, 215 – part of the end rotation; will play often 
• Jordan Key, Sophomore, 6-2, 235 – part of the tackle rotation 
• Frank Sinatra, Senior, 5-11, 215 – part of the tackle rotation 
• Joe Amadeo, Sophomore, 6-0, 250 – part of the tackle rotation 
• Gavin O’Malley, Senior, 5-11, 230 – part of the tackle rotation 
• Michael Barry, Senior, 6-0, 210 – part of the tackle rotation 

Linebacker: 

• Jamie Gutridge, Senior, 5-9, 195 – returning starter 
• Matt Lonczak, Senior, 5-9, 200 – returning starter 
• Patrick McGonnell, Senior, 6-3, 205 – returning starter 
• Gio Olmo, Senior, 5-11, 210 – returning starter 
• John Outerie, Junior, 5-11, 200 – provides depth 
• Luke Scaturro, Sophomore, 5-8, 180 – provides depth 
• TJ Walsh, Sophomore, 6-2, 210 – provides depth 

Secondary: 

• Blake Caruso, Junior, 5-11, 180 – returning starter at safety 
• Daniel Zabora, Junior, 6-3, 185 – competing at safety 
• Gavin Richter, Junior, 6-0, 180 – competing at safety; St. John Vianney transfer 
• Jordan Mosenthine, Sophomore, 5-10, 180 – competing at safety 
• Alex Nicolas, Junior, 5-10, 175 – projected starter at cornerback 
• Curtis O’Brien, Junior, 6-0, 175 – competing at cornerback 
• Johnny Williams, Junior, 5-9, 160 – competing at cornerback 
• Reyes Quinones, Senior, 6-0, 175 – competing at cornerback 
• Frankie Tackett, Junior, 5-9, 170 – competing at cornerback 

Special Teams:  

• Junior Blake Caruso will be the kicker and punter 
• Johnny WIllams and Mosenthine are the return men 

Schedule: 

• Thursday, 8/29, at Middletown (Del.) 
• Friday, 9/6, Don Bosco at home 
• Saturday, 9/14, at Long Branch 
• Saturday, 9/21, at Colts Neck 
• Saturday, 9/28, at Marlboro 
• 10/4-5, Bye Week 
• Friday, 10/11, Rumson-Fair Haven at home 
• Friday, 10/18, Paramus Catholic at home 
• Friday, 10/25, Middletown South at home 
• Friday, 11/1, Donovan Catholic at home 

Concerns: 

• Youth 
• How they handle themselves up front on both sides 

Recruiting: 

• Frankie Williams has interest from James Madison, Temple, Holy Cross, and Fordham 
• Forsyth, Matt Lonczak, and Gutridge are receiving Patriot League interest 
• McGonnell has interest from Fordham and Bryant 
• Olmo is drawing interest from Wagner 
• Sinatra and O’Malley are D2 candidates 
• Others may play with a good year 
• Underclassmen: 
• Zabora has interest from James Madison, Boston College, and Temple 
• Lorenzo Tartamella is a sophomore with offers from Syracuse, Boston College, Pittsburgh, West Virginia, and James Madison 
• Other sophomores with interest are Key and Walsh 
• This is a strong sophomore class and more will come forward as prospects 

Coach’s Comments: 

“We have key players back, but we graduated a lot. There is good young talent and we have more depth than we have had in a few years. We have to reinvent our lines, but the quarterback is in his third year as a starter and that’s always good. We’re excited.” – Head Coach Mike Lange